cryingvalor

Hey guys in our office we have a domain network with DNS... and i have been
reading some ebooks about netbios, wins, dns and ad. and it get me really
confuse. if i have already setup DNS in our network and implement AD. do i
still have to implement or worry about netbios and WINS?

newhouse1390

WINS is an implementation of the NetBIOS P-node server. What this means is that Windows PCs can find each other on the network by registering themselves with a centralized server, then asking that server about other PCs.
Contrast with NetBIOS

NetBIOS was developed in the mid-1980s by IBM, Sytek, and Microsoft. Its purpose was to allow PCs to communicate over a local area network, especially IBM's 3mbps Ethernet-like cable service as well as IBM's later Token Ring LANs.

It allows NetBIOS-aware applications to communicate regardless of the underlying infrastructure. For example, on the older Windows PCs, you have the choice of installing NetBEUI (NetBIOS raw over Ethernet) or NetBIOS over Novell's IPX. Yet another option is NetBIOS over TCP/IP.

WINS is just a component of the NetBIOS over TCP/IP implementation. It is not used with NetBIOS over any other transport.

Contrast with DNS

WINS is similar to DNS: both systems will resolve a name into an IP address. DNS solves the general Internet naming problem, WINS is designed only for NetBIOS names. It is only used in the cases where NetBIOS applications (such as Windows File and Print Services) need to talk to each other.

However, Microsoft makes "helper" services. If you need a DNS name but one cannot be found, Windows will lookup the name in the WINS server. Similarly, if a NetBIOS name cannot be found in the WINS server, Windows will attempt to lookup the name in the DNS server. This means that while WINS and DNS have completely different heritages that know nothing of each other, they effectively become interchangeable.

WINS vs. no-WINS

WINS isn't necessary for all communication. NetBIOS has been designed around a "broadcast" mechanism. The default Windows behavior is to simply broadcast information on the local network. Installing a WINS server (and configuring the clients to use it) will reduce broadcast traffic. Also, since broadcasts do not travel across subnets, WINS may be the only way that two distant machines can find each other.

Port 42-WINS databases exchange information on port 42
Port 137-NetBIOS name traffic travels across port 137.
RFC1001
RFC1002
SNMP WINS deletion-WINS database entries can be deleted through an exposed SNMP interface.

crazijoe

If your environment is all Win2K or Win2K3 servers and Win2K and or WinXP client machines, It may be best to just use DNS and not WINS.