koala

Hi Jake, welcome to TSF

If you've never used a photo editor, it will be difficult for us to give simple instructions. Post back here with the photos, and one of our Photoshop users will have a go at fixing the problem.

Basically, you need to copy the eyes from one photo and paste them onto a new layer in another photo, then rotate, resize, blend the skin tones, etc until they match.

If you don't want the photos to be seen on a public forum, you can send them to me via PM.